Skip to content

A Crippling Bargain: How Trump's School Vouchers Decimate Education

11.19.26
Boy writing on notebook at his desk

Our students’ educational futures are at stake, and the Trump administration's school vouchers program is just the latest veiled attack on our public schools. California must say no. Read on to find out more.

The current moment  

Public education is one of our nation's greatest investments in our children’s, communities’, and collective future. At its best, it is a promise that every child, regardless of their race, income, ability, language, religion, gender, or zip code, will have access to a high-quality education that prepares them to thrive.  

Because of what it represents, public education has long been the target of coordinated efforts to weaken and privatize it throughout history. Billionaires, right-wing think tanks, and conservative political leaders have sought to replace a public education that serves all with one that advances ultra-conservative, white Christian nationalist political, financial, and cultural interests. The current Trump administration has accelerated this long-standing agenda, making public education a central battleground in a broader effort to shrink who counts, silence what does not fit, and control what the next generation believes about themselves and each other.  

One of the Trump administration's latest tools to advance this agenda is the expansion of private school vouchers. Voucher programs provide government-funded certificates, scholarships, or tax credits that redirect public tax dollars to pay for private school tuition or other educational services—incentivizing families to unenroll their children from public school. When public dollars are increasingly redirected toward private schools, we weaken the public schools that serve as anchors in our communities: the places where families come together to learn across differences, access critical services and support, and develop the skills of democratic participation. The administration’s efforts are therefore not simply an educational agenda to undermine public education, but a broader effort to weaken the institutions that underpin our democracy.  

Attempts to expand vouchers rely on two myths about private schools:

  1. Diverting public funds to them will improve educational opportunity and access
  2. Private schools consistently provide a better education than public schools

Both are false.

First, while many families seek vouchers in the hopes of using them for private school tuition, many American families remain unable to access private schools. Vouchers often do not cover the full cost of tuition, leaving many families unable to pay the remaining expenses while subsidizing tuition for wealthy families already accessing private education. In rural communities, geographical proximity to a private school is extremely limited. Private schools also often lack supports for students with disabilities or English learners, and their admission practices may bar certain students from attending in the first place.

Second, a significant body of evidence from state voucher programs shows that students who use vouchers often perform no better, and sometimes worse, than their peers remaining in public schools. By promoting the expansion of a program that is harmful or delivers mixed results at best, the federal administration places our students’ educational futures at stake.  

While American families have justifiably been concerned about the quality of public education, vouchers do not solve this problem. Instead, they divert public resources away from the schools that serve 85% of American students and shift those resources to private institutions that do not have the responsibility to educate all students. We must target our investments to build a public education system that is racially just, serves all California students by ensuring full, adequate funding and resources, and builds shared power with students, families, and their communities, so that public education can act as a powerful equalizer, offering access to opportunity for all.  

The real story of school vouchers
Nationally

School voucher policies are not only harmful, but they have an incredibly racist history. After the Supreme Court ruled in Brown v. Board of Education in 1954 that segregated public schools were unconstitutional, white lawmakers across the Southern states organized to resist desegregation in their school districts. Because Brown's ruling only applied to public schools, the lawmakers pushed white students into private schools to maintain segregated school systems. maintain segregated school systems. 

To make private schools accessible to white families resisting integration, states created "tuition grants"—publicly funded money for private education—akin to modern day vouchers. In the late 1950s and 1960s, hundreds of “segregation academies,” as they would later be called, emerged in the Southern states. The grants helped white families pay for private schools that excluded Black students, while Black students were left in public school systems that remained segregated, underfunded, or in some cases, closed altogether.

By the late 1960s, federal courts had struck down tuition-grant programs in several Southern states finding that public funding could not be used to sustain racially segregated private schools. Yet, the underlying policy mechanism of directing public funds to private education is still alive in modern voucher programs.

Text box describing PEC case

This history serves as a critical warning of what happens when public funds are used to create two vastly different education systems that deepen inequities and weaken the systems designed to serve every child. As the Trump administration continues to expand voucher programs, we must be vigilant against their intent to deepen educational inequity by undermining a public education system that strives for equal access and opportunity. 

In California 

While early efforts to create and implement voucher programs began in the Southern states, California is not immune to attempts to implement voucher programs. Republican lawmakers and voucher advocacy groups have introduced multiple statewide ballot initiatives and legislation to establish ways to use public funds for private schools. Although to date all proposals have failed to advance in California, the ongoing federal overreach to bring vouchers into states that have repeatedly rejected them demonstrates that California will continue to face these threats.  

With these continuing attempts, we must also raise awareness and understanding in California’s families around vouchers. In California, a poll conducted by the Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC) in 2026 revealed that 73% of Californians opposed a proposed initiative to require the state to deposit annual voucher payments for students attending religious and other private schools. However, in response to the question of whether they support providing tax-funded vouchers to send their children to any public, private, or parochial school, only 52% of participants opposed.

This reduced margin seemingly contradicts the earlier data point, highlighting the need to further dispel myths around vouchers, particularly the myth that private schools systematically offer a higher-quality education than public schools. 

Table showing school voucher initiatives introduced in the CA Legislature
Why should we care about vouchers?

The evidence demonstrates that voucher programs do not meaningfully expand educational opportunities. Instead, they reinforce and potentially exacerbate existing educational inequalities. Rather than expanding educational opportunity for students that most need it, vouchers are most accessible to families that already have the resources, proximity, and capital to navigate the private school system.  

Vouchers do not improve students’ educational outcomes

One of the primary justifications for school voucher programs is the belief that granting students the opportunity to attend private schools will improve their academic outcomes. This assumption has been rigorously studied for decades. Time and time again, researchers find that voucher programs do not lead to improved academic outcomes for the students that receive them and may even have negative impacts. While some private schools may have higher average test scores and college admissions, research consistently shows that these differences are largely explained by family income, parental education, and selective admissions. When controlling for these factors, private schools do not lead to improved outcomes compared to public schools. 

A Department of Education evaluation of Washington D.C.'s Opportunity Scholarship Program found that the program had no impact on students' academic achievement in math or reading, and no statistically significant impact on parental satisfaction or involvement as well. A study conducted on the Louisiana Scholarship Program found that students receiving vouchers had negative academic impacts, especially in math and no statistically significant difference in college entrance.

These findings have been replicated across multiple states, all sharing the same result. Voucher programs consistently fail to deliver on their central promise of improving educational outcomes for students. The lack of evidence that voucher programs improve educational outcomes makes the federal administration’s push for their expansion especially concerning.

Vouchers destabilize our public education system

Vouchers divert funds from public schools that educate 85% of America's students, to pay for private educational expenses for the few that receive them. Because public school funding is largely tied to attendance and enrollment, every student that leaves a public school with a voucher reduces the funding available to their local public school. However, most of a school's costs like transportation, utilities, staffing, and facilities remain fixed regardless of whether students leave. As a result, schools are left with fewer resources for key investments that benefit all students, such as smaller class sizes, increased teacher pay, or enhanced extracurriculars. 

In addition, vouchers funded via tax credits reduce available funding overall for public education and services. At the federal level, programs like Title I that support low-income students, Title III that support English learners, and the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) that support students with disabilities, lose potential funding that is diverted to private education. Rather than truly addressing the challenges that are plaguing public education, namely lack of funding, vouchers redirect these public resources towards private educational expenses for individual families.  

Additionally, voucher programs can deepen the financial strain on public schools by changing the makeup of students who remain in the system. Private schools are not required to fully meet educational needs for students with disabilities or English learners, nor are they required to admit every applicant. As a result, public schools often have a greater percentage of students that need additional support while operating with fewer resources, while private schools educate students with less needs but ample resources. This concentrates need and inequity in the public system while directing taxpayer funds to a private system that often already has greater resources.  

Vouchers lack accountability and transparency

Schools participating in voucher programs lack many of the standards that public schools must follow to receive funds and operate with far fewer safeguards in place to ensure that public dollars are spent responsibly. A 2017 review by the Government Accountability Office (GAO) of 27 state voucher programs found that oversight requirements varied widely. Approximately one-third of the programs lacked academic or administrative accountability measures, and fewer than one-third required annual financial audits.

In many states, private schools participating in voucher programs are not mandated to keep track of student academic and demographic data, administer state testing, employ credentialed teachers, or follow curriculum aligned with the state. In Florida, investigative journalists found voucher recipient schools had hired teachers without college degrees and falsified health and safety records. Currently in California, the California Department of Education does not have authority to evaluate, approve, or oversee the operations of private schools. If the state opted in, these weak oversight measures would have real consequences for students who may receive subpar quality education.  

Voucher programs also provide taxpayers with less transparency into how public dollars are distributed and spent. The structure of many voucher programs creates opportunities for fraud, waste, and abuse when public dollars move through private organizations that have limited budget reporting and disclosure requirements. As a result, taxpayers have fewer ways to understand how public funds are being spent and ultimately who benefits from them. Scholarship granting organizations (SGOs), rather than public education agencies, have significant discretion over which students receive vouchers, what those funds are used for, and what data they collect and maintain about participating students. Without meaningful transparency about who receives vouchers and how those funds are spent, it is harder to identify discriminatory allocation practices, whether dollars are supporting legitimate educational services, or whether organizations are prioritizing their own financial interests over students.     

Vouchers weaken civil rights protections 

Scholarship granting organizations and private schools are also not required to meet the same civil rights obligations that federally funded public schools are required to meet. As a result, children from historically marginalized groups including students of color, students with disabilities, English learners, LGBTQ+ students, and students from religious minority backgrounds are susceptible to unfair and unjust treatment at their schools with little to no avenues for recourse. This unjust treatment can happen in the admissions process or once the child has been enrolled at the school. When it comes to admissions, private schools have greater discretion over whom they admit and can reject students for many reasons that public schools cannot, such as due to their religion, aptitude, behavior, ability, or language status. Once enrolled, students may also face disciplinary policies, or families may face pressure to withdraw without the same procedural protections available in the public school system.   

For students with disabilities, private schools participating in voucher programs are not required to provide the same special educational services, develop or implement an Individualized Education Program (IEP), or offer the same due process protections that a public school would. Parents who voluntarily enroll their child into a private school waive their child's right to a Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) under the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA). English learners (EL) are also more vulnerable to gaps in inadequate language services when attending private schools. In California, for EL students to receive federally funded Title III language services, their private school must elect to participate and coordinate with a local educational agency (LEA) which oversees and provides the services. However, there is no penalty for private schools that decline to participate in the Title III program. These differences mean that even if a student receives a voucher, the private school they attend may not be required to provide the same educational services, civil rights protections, and opportunities available to students in public schools. All the while, the public school system may be responsible for providing these services while not receiving the per-pupil funding needed to fully support those students.  

These gaps in protections and services have significant implications in California, where there are over 880,000 students with disabilities and over 920,000 English learners. If voucher programs expand, these students could face greater barriers to accessing the specialized services they are entitled to in public schools.  

Vouchers foster an inequitable education

The claim that vouchers will help low- and moderate-income families falls apart when looking at the factors that impact who is able to make use of a voucher. Barriers such as remaining tuition costs, selective admissions, the availability of and proximity to private schools mean that the families best positioned to take advantage of voucher programs are often those with children already enrolled in private schools.  

On average, private school tuition in California is $18,000 per year. However, there is a wide range in cost based on the grade level, mission, or location with price tags ranging from $7,000 to well over $60,000. Vouchers are typically not enough to fully fund private school tuition for a low-income student but could easily subsidize private education for a more affluent family. In Arizona, an estimated 71% of voucher recipients were previously privately educated, and in Oklahoma—where the median household income is $65,000—over 40% of the voucher recipients were families making more than $150,000 per year.  

Due to racial income inequality, these issues are further exacerbated by race, with white students being overrepresented in private schools and voucher programs. Nationally, Black students account for 9% of private school enrollment compared to 15% of public school enrollment, while Hispanic students make up 12% of private schools and 28% of public schools. In Texas's universal voucher program, data shows that 45% of voucher applicants were white, even though white students only make up 25% of the state's public school enrollment. Together, these disproportionalities raise concerns that voucher programs may reinforce and exacerbate existing racial inequities in private school education—reminiscent of segregation academies—without addressing the underlying barriers to access.  

Inequality also exists due to the locations of private schools, as they are concentrated in urban areas. Nationally, only 44% of rural families live within five miles of a private school, compared with 87% of urban families. Data from West Virginia’s HOPE Scholarship Program revealed that there were zero voucher recipients in rural McDowell County in the 2023-24 school year, where one in three residents is below the poverty line. In the 2025-26 school year, four California counties lacked private schools entirely, while 21 counties had fewer than 10. On the flip side, Los Angeles County had 820 private schools serving over 140,000 students. If California were to adopt a voucher program, families in rural counties would be subsidizing the private education of students from more populous counties.

CA map showing counties with private schools
What is to come with the federal program?

After decades of failed attempts to create a federal voucher program, the second Trump administration succeeded in enacting H.R. 1, one of the most sweeping and harmful federal budget overhauls in decades. In a law that slashed funding to essential programs such as Medicaid and SNAP while funneling billions of dollars to tax cuts for the wealthy, it comes as no surprise that the first nationwide federal tax-credit voucher program formally known as the "Federal Scholarship Tax Credit program" was also included. The voucher program's inclusion reflects the administration's broader agenda to dismantle a public education system that millions of families depend on to educate their children.  

According to the newly released proposed regulations, the federal voucher program allows taxpayers to receive a 100% federal tax credit for contributions up to $1,700 made to a scholarship granting organization. Unlike a charitable donation to nonprofit organizations which only reduces taxable income via a tax deduction, a 100% tax credit completely reimburses the taxpayer for their donation to the SGO. In fact, there are only three other examples of 100% tax credits in the federal tax code, none of which are related to charitable giving. The rarity of this structure is significant because it signals the administration’s use of an exceptionally uncommon tax tool to advance a program that destabilizes public education.   

SGOs are eligible nonprofit organizations responsible for collecting these contributions and using the funds to distribute vouchers to families. Voucher funds may be used to cover qualified K-12 education expenses including, but not limited to, tuition and fees, tutoring, books and supplies, uniforms, and transportation. These SGOs can retain up to 10% of contributions for "administrative expenses" potentially allowing billions of taxpayer dollars to be used to fund the operations, marketing, and personnel of these private organizations.  

The proposed federal regulations declare that states have little control over any rules and regulations that SGOs in their state must comply with. The program does not require reporting on students’ demographic or academic outcomes, and states cannot impose data collection or testing requirements. They also cannot limit SGO participation to those that would serve public school students. Rather, the SGOs have significant discretion over voucher distribution, award amounts, eligibility criteria, organizational missions, and administrative spending—all with little to no opportunity for the public to understand where their tax dollars are going.  

While proponents argue that the voucher program could benefit public schools by allowing students to receive vouchers for tutoring, special needs services, or other educational uses, in reality this is not the case. Under the California Constitution and state law, public schools generally cannot charge students fees for such activities. These services must be provided free of charge. As a result, vouchers would be used on private vendors, taking public funds out of public schools. Additionally, given that the regulations restrict states from requiring SGOs to prioritize public school students or only select SGOs that fund public school students, California has few to no means to ensure public students are the primary beneficiaries of the program.  

To qualify for the program, a state's governor, designated state official, or legislative body must opt that state into the program each year. Only students residing in states that are opted in are eligible to receive vouchers. When a state opts in, it must provide a list of SGOs that will operate the program. As of mid-November, 32 states have announced plans to opt in to the program. Most states that have opted in did so via their Republican leadership, while only one state opted in via their Democratic leadership. California is one of the remaining states that has not yet announced a decision.  

Conceptual map of state response to national vouchers

Although voucher advocates often uplift vouchers as a way to expand educational opportunity to low-income children, the federal program’s only income eligibility requirement to receive a voucher is that a student’s annual family income must not exceed 300% of the area median income (AMI). This equates to 96% of American students being eligible across the country. In some areas in California, this income threshold qualifies families earning over $600,000 per year. Clearly, this demonstrates that funds are not guaranteed to go to students from low-income backgrounds, and in fact, marks a shift away from the equity and goals of some means-tested voucher programs to target students with the greatest financial needs.  

The structure of the program highlights the nefarious nature of this administration's broad effort to redirect public resources away from the communities and institutions they are intended to serve and instead direct them to privatized alternatives. Rather than creating such a preferential tax treatment for investments into public education, affordable housing, or food pantries, the administration is providing a blank check to unregulated SGOs, wealthy families, and billionaires on the backs of American public school students.  

Because the cost of the program is dependent on the uptake of taxpayers that donate to SGOs, the cost of the program remains uncertain. According to an analysis by the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, if a quarter of voucher supporters donate the full $1,700 or more to SGOs, the program would cost taxpayers more than $25 billion per year, more than the Title I program receives. On the other hand, official estimates from the Congressional Joint Committee on Taxation estimate the program to cost around $4 billion per year with the Treasury Department estimating it will cost $26 billion by 2030. While the true cost remains undetermined, the rapid expansion of voucher costs in many states suggests that federal costs could increase significantly as more taxpayers begin to utilize the credit.  

California must opt out

Given the research and the true underlying intentions behind the Trump administration’s efforts to dismantle public education, California must set an example for the nation and opt out of the federal school voucher program—both for 2027 and every year thereafter while the program is operational. As of mid-November, Minnesota, Oregon, and Wisconsin have announced their plans to decline opting in. The newly released regulations underscore these risks and further reveal the program being structured to use federal tax dollars for the expansion of private education at the expense of public schools and the students that rely on them.  

Not only must California avoid adopting school vouchers, but we must disrupt and demystify inaccurate prevailing narratives and myths surrounding vouchers. Thus far, each time voters across the country have had the opportunity to weigh in at the ballot box regarding voucher programs, they have rejected them. Instead, states with statewide voucher programs established them through legislative action. Similarly, California voters have historically shut down voucher program ballot initiatives, and the majority do not support using taxpayer dollars to fund students to attend private schools. However, given the aforementioned mixed results of public polling around the use of tax-funded vouchers and recent narratives claiming that vouchers could be beneficial for public schools, we must refute the myths around vouchers and expose the truth to communities and local and state leaders throughout California of the well-documented harms voucher programs pose to public education and most importantly, students.  

The evidence makes it clear: California’s state leaders must unequivocally opt out and not fall victim to the administration’s smokescreen that is the federal school voucher program created by H.R. 1, one of the most devastating laws the country has seen under the Trump administration. We must collectively fight harmful narratives that promote this agenda. Vouchers are one of the many tactics leveraged by this administration to decimate public education and reinforce its authoritarian agenda. As California continues to face the ongoing threat of encroaching vouchers, we must actively organize against school vouchers and ensure that state leaders continue to stay the course in opting out.